Get INCREDIBLE guitar secrets you won’t find anywhere else!
Subscribe to our mailing list!

* indicates required
Close
The Guitar Principles  
The TRUTH about Learning Guitar
 
The Basics > Practice Theory > Guitar Practice and Building Speed: Vital Info

Guitar Practice and Building Speed: Vital Info



Here is an excellent question from one of my readers concerning building speed on guitar that brings up a great area of  confusion for guitar students. It shows how careful we must be when listening to the advice of great players.

 

Hi Jamie,

I have a question about picking and building up to higher speeds.

I read somewhere that the late, great Shawn Lane once said, “Generally speaking, when practicing fast licks, it is supposed to be better to practice at a slow tempo and build up to speed. But my idea is ‘play as fast as you can even if you make mistakes.’ In the beginning, you may lack precision but you can get over that. First gain speed and gradually get clearer. It’s a better way - at least I think so.”

This runs counter to what you and most other instructors teach. Obviously it worked for Shawn so it can’t be completely flawed, but is there anything of value in this statement for normal humans?

In a similar vein, Michael Angelo recommends picking as fast as you can first, then using that motion as your basic template for picking technique and practicing slow from there on, the idea being that the first picking-hand position you go with is the most natural and comfortable for you (I’m assuming this isn’t directed at complete beginners). Where do you stand on that idea?

Thanks for any comments and keep up the good work,

Bill

 

Hi Bill,

Those are very interesting questions, and even though the contentions made are almost diametrically opposed to what I and many other teachers would advise, I think they deserve examination, and I even believe there is value to be discovered. In any case, as you say, when a great player says something, I always listen closely. They may not understand completely all the implications or related factors of what they are saying, but there is most likely something valid in their perceptions.

First of all, yes, I think we can safely assume that these procedures worked for these people, at least some of the time, and at least at some period in their development. However, we have no way of knowing if they could solve all their problems this way, and if they at times needed to employ other methods. We have no way of knowing if there were things they wanted to do and never were able to do, because these methods were not sufficient. And, we have no way of knowing if these methods only became effective after a certain period of technical development had taken place.

I think we should keep these uncertainties in mind when examining this issue.

And as long as we are talking about things that we can and cannot be certain of, I will tell you this without a doubt: for the vast majority of people attempting to learn guitar, these methods will bring these methods of practice and problem solving will bring almost insurmountably disastrous results! I am talking about technique that is so flawed, so limited, and so ingrained into the players muscle memory that most people, without the benefit of the remedial techniques GuitarPrinciples offers, will simply never overcome them.

So, what is going on here?

I really think that when Shawn Lane says “in learning a new lick, just keep playing it over and over. The mistakes will gradually get worked out and it will get cleaner”, he is talking about learning a lick that is already well within the level of your ability. It is on the same plane as your HORIZONTAL GROWTH at the present time. It does not contain movements that are beyond you at the moment, things you cannot do comfortably or smoothly at any speed.

There are many things I can play perfectly at sight, having never seen the music before. That is because (aside from knowing the neck well), there is nothing there I have not seen a million times before, and nothing there I cannot execute with almost no conscious thought. Then, there are things I can play pretty well, perhaps not up to tempo, and perhaps with some mistakes. I will have to work on them a bit, because they are simply more complex, and perhaps contain movements I am not so familiar with, or are completely new. Perhaps I need actual physical development of some muscle or nerve connection to play it well.

Then, there are really difficult things I have never played before. The best players have to take months to perhaps a year to do the kind of analysis and practice necessary for extremely difficult music (and bring it to “performance level”). It is very important to keep in mind that many styles, especially improvised styles, use a relatively small number of discretely different movement patterns. If you are a rock or blues player, most likely, you are doing essentially the same movements, perhaps in different contexts and with different inflections, throughout your whole playing life. Even new licks are not too different than the ones you know. Of course, every player is going to fall somewhere on this spectrum in terms of variability of movement patterns, and that will influence the practice methods you find effece.

Auto Correct

I actually have a name for this idea of “doing something over and over until it starts coming out right”. I call it “auto-correct”. I use it myself, and I use it with students. However, it is important to know how to use it, when to use it, and especially, when not to use it.

I may have a student sitting in front of me, playing something we have worked on awhile. They may mess up a passage, and I will say “okay, take that part again”. But, I will add these extremely important words “increase your attention and intention before and during this next attempt”. In other words, some mistakes will occur simply because we are not paying enough attention to what we are doing, or, even more likely, are not thinking ahead to our next series of movements, including hearing the music in our heads as we play. So, my first line of attack with mistakes where music has already been practiced is “auto-correct”. It very well may happen that by simply going over the passage a few times with strong mental focus (and it is always a big help to play it mentally before each new attempt), it starts to improve. But, if the mistake does not yield to this approach, it is a good indication that something else is going on, that the problem is not in the mind, so to speak, but in the fingers.

It could be bad fingering, unclear fingering, erratic fingering, physical tension in any part of the body; a million different things. At that point, a diagnostic process of analysis must be conducted, and there is only one way to do it. If you doggedly stick with “auto-correct”, the methods you have asked me about, you are going to be a seriously frustrated guitarist, because when the problem is of this nature, IT DOES NOT FIX ITSELF!

Another point to appreciate is this: in my book “The Deeper I Go”, I define intelligence as “responsive awareness”. I also make the point that there are many domains of intelligence, and physical intelligence is one of them. Some people’s bodies are more naturally “responsively aware” than others. For these people, auto-correct is going to work at an earlier date in their development, and more strongly. However, all of us can teach our bodies to be responsively aware, to be “intelligent”, that is what proper training is all about. The more sophisticated our technique becomes through training, the more “auto-correct” will work for us, and in increasingly complex situations.

When Auto Correct Doesn't Work

But, much more important than all of this is to know what to do when auto-correct is not solving our problem, which is 99% of the time! What must be done is, essentially, the Basic Practice Approach (the fundamental practice methodology taught in Chapter 5 of "The Principles Of Correct Practice For Guitar"). I will say to the student having trouble with something, “play the passage for me no tempo, show me the bottom of your practice”. This means "Show me your slowest and most focused practice of these notes".  That will tell me all I need to know. I will see the discomfort the student is truly experiencing (without knowing it), and I will see what they are doing to create or exacerbate that discomfort. I see what is wrong, why it is wrong, and what to do about it, and then we get to work.

Expanding Upon A Basic “Template”

Now let’s talk about this other idea of learning a skill by simply having a go at it as fast as you can, observing the action, and assuming that the details of that action are the best possible ones for you to use, and so should be developed.

Well, my first reaction is “try it, see how it works”. I imagine it may be a good idea, and bring good and MAYBE the best results for some very few people, but again, all of my decades of teaching experience have shown me otherwise. In fact, my basic attitude is, all things being equal, the untrained fingers are incredibly stupid, and can almost always be depended upon to do things in the worst way possible. In fact, it would usually be better to watch what your fingers do, and then train them to do just the opposite!

Now, please remember I am not laying down hard and fast “this is the way it is for everybody all the time” type of rules, because there are none. There are so many variables involved in this whole subject that no rules could ever hold true always. My philosophy is to listen to everybody, think about everything, try everything you have a mind to, and then assess and analyze results. We just really need to be careful in this whole endeavor. I would not be surprised that someone who based their picking technique on the first available action template that presented itself would never know whether they were, by doing so, making many other skills inaccessible to themselves down the road. We frequently hear of long time players who wish they could change this or that about their technique, having discovered superior approaches later in life.

So, those are my thoughts concerning the provocative statements made by these great players. If I were to summarize my reaction to the substance of your questions concerning the statements of these players of great natural talent who, as great players often will, have temporarily taken on the role of teachers, I would say this: it is a perfect illustration of why so often great players are lousy teachers, unless they are teaching already great players!



article 1
Playing Plateaus - How To Get Off!
Every guitar player gets stuck on a plateau from time to time, unable to get better on guitar. Here is what the great players do..................
> Read More...
article 2
Creating Coordination with Coupling
Coupling is the bringing together, into one playing moment and motion, of two or more events necessary to produce a note. It is done by intense focus on the tactile sensations of fingers on strings.
> Read More...
article 3
Measuring Your Progress On Guitar
Guitar students practice every day, but often have no idea if they are making any progress. There are ways of measuring your progress on guitar, and we have to know them, and use them.
> Read More...
article 4
Guitar Speed Exercises: Are They Working For You?
You can find guitar speed exercises all over the web, and in thousands of books. Many guitar students have a pile of these books, but no speed in their fingers. Here's why!
> Read More...
article 5
It's Not A Problem, It's A Process
Attitude is everything when it comes to learning guitar. Learning how to see every problem as a process is the key to becoming a great guitar player. In this article, I explain how to do this.
> Read More...
article 6
Practicing One Thing is Practicing Everything!
If you know how to learn one thing really well on guitar, you know how to learn anything. If you cannot learn one thing well, you cannot learn anything well. Correct practice changes everything!
> Read More...
article 7
9 Questions to Ask Yourself When You Practice
Here are 9 critical things you MUST be aware of when you practice guitar. Lack of awareness of these things is the root of endless problems.
> Read More...
article 8
Perfection & Guitar Playing
What does "perfection" mean for a guitar player. You'd better know, or you could be causing yourself a lot of agony!
> Read More...
article 9
Playing From The String
"Playing From The String" is one of the secrets of the masters of guitar. All good players are doing this, even if they don't know what it means! Here's what it mean.....
> Read More...
article 10
The 5 Minute Practice Session
Finding a block of time for guitar practice is sometimes difficult. Don't go for days without touching those strings you love! Learn how to make solid progress in just 5 minutes!
> Read More...
article 11
Am I Too Old To Learn Guitar?
A lot of "grown ups" want to fulfill their lifelong dream of playing the guitar. But. one nasty, nagging doubt holds them back. Cheer up...here's the good news!
> Read More...
article 12
Natural Talent - Do I Need It?
What is "natural talent" for guitar? Few people know, yet many people are sure they don't have it when it comes to guitar! Here is what "natural talent" really means......
> Read More...
article 13
The 2 Types of Growth On Guitar: Horizontal & Vertical
There are two kinds of growth we can experience on guitar. I call them Vertical & Horizontal Growth.Both are necessary, but Vertical growth is hard to come by!
> Read More...
article 14
Agressive Guitar Practice
Many guitar students make little or no progress because their practicing is not aggressive enough. When you practice, your mind must have the energy of a hurricane and the tenacity of a pit bull!
> Read More...
article 15
Review Is Required
Reviewing material we have already worked on, and applying our new and improved skills is essential for reaching our full potential on guitar.
> Read More...
article 16
Guitar Principles Recommended Metronomes
A metronome is necessary for guitar practice. Some metronomes are better than others when it comes to doing powerful and correct practice.
> Read More...
article 17
Why You Should Use A Metronome For Guitar Practice
Knowing how to use a metronome when you practice guitar WILL make you a better player! Here's why...
> Read More...
article 18
Double Trouble
Sometimes the way to make something better on guitar is to make it worse first!
> Read More...
article 19
The Importance Of Repertoire
If you have played guitar for more than six months and you do not have a few things you can play from beginning to end, something is seriously wrong!
> Read More...
article 20
Changing Bad Habits On Guitar
Virtually all beginners on guitar unknowingly form bad habits. They can last for decades, making you less of a guitar player than you can be. Here is how to get rid of your bad habits.
> Read More...
article 21
Guitar Practice Organization
Here's how to find the time for guitar practice and how to organize it. There are 4 essential categories of practice you must organize in your guitar practice schedule...here they are...
> Read More...
you might also like
Technique vs. Musical Feeling
Read More...
Guitar Foundation Exercises
Read More...
Play "Day Tripper"!
Read More...
Finger Rise: A Disease of the Left Hand
Read More...
 
IN THIS SECTION
Playing Plateaus - How To Get Off!
Guitar Practice and Building Speed: Vital Info
Creating Coordination with Coupling
Measuring Your Progress On Guitar
NEWSLETTER SIGNUP
RECEIVE “THE POWER OF TEN”
We Never Email More then Once a Week.
Upon signup receive 10 ARTICLES THAT WILL TRANSFORM YOUR GUITAR PLAYING.
FEATURED CONTENT
The Principles of Correct Practice for Guitar-Hard Copy
Why Is The Principles The Best Way to Learn Guitar?

156 - Why Is The Principles The Best Way to Learn Guitar?

All other guitar methods have serious flaws that leave you struggling on guitar. The Principles is different....
Learn To Play a Guitar by Learning HOW to Practice!

16 - Learn To Play a Guitar by Learning HOW to Practice!

Everything that happens when you play is the direct result of what you do when you practice. Learn to train your fingers EFFECTIVELY when you practice guitar.
Your First Perfect Guitar Lesson

18 - Your First Perfect Guitar Lesson

Many guitar players carry for a lifetime the mistakes they learned when first learning how to play the instrument... Tips to avoid this can be found here!
What Are The Principles?

15 - What Are The Principles?

Those who know "The Principles" know that there is no other guitar method like it. It is the key to using every other method! Find out for yourself.....