Get INCREDIBLE guitar secrets you won’t find anywhere else!
Subscribe to our mailing list!

* indicates required
Close
 
The TRUTH about Learning Guitar
 
The Basics > Practice Theory > Perfection & Guitar Playing
Perfection & Guitar Playing



Hi Jamie,

Just a question about your own playing, When you were about aged 21-22 had you reached a sense of technical perfection? Was there anything you couldn’t play?

Thanks...Charles

 

Hi Charles,

I am tempted to tell you “yes, Charles, at age 21, I had reached a state of technical perfection, and, in fact, there was nothing I could not play”. I’m tempted to tell you that just for the fun of it. But instead, just between me and you, I’ll tell you the truth!

Here is the short version. No, I had not reached a state of technical perfection at 21, and no, I still haven’t at 46! What I have achieved is the understanding that there is no such thing as a state of technical perfection. I have also reached the understanding that the best players do not even think in those terms. The best players, if they ever thought they had reached some state of perfection, would immediately set out to find something wrong with their playing, something they could improve, something to challenge them and keep the whole thing interesting.

They would be like Pable Casals at 90, when asked why he still practiced, he said “I find I am getting better” (Casals was considered by many to be the greatest player of ANY instrument throughout the 20ths century).

No, Charles, there is no such thing as “technical perfection” in terms of some absolute state. There are just things you can do, and things you can’t do. And there is just the ability to understand WHY you can’t do certain things, and then the ability to DO something about it to change the situation.

I am answering your question, (and I am glad, in your innocence, you asked it) because the attitude from which the question proceeds is the MAIN obstacle to yours, or anyone else’s progress on the instrument. And that attitude is there for very good reasons. The biggest reason that attitude is in place, and maintained in its place, is because it is perpetuated by so many players, and people who have something to gain by having advanced players looked at as somehow more than human, as somehow enjoying a state attainable by only the elect few. And the common people are allowed to gaze admiringly, but should understand that they themselves are not cut from the same superhuman cloth. Look, but don’t touch!


Answering your question, Charles, brought to mind something I had written about a year ago on this subject. I think it bears repeating:

This word “perfection” is one of those very dangerous words we use. We use the word as if it actually referred to something. We use it as if there were things that were “perfect”, or people that are “perfect”, or guitarists that are “perfect” (we usually use the word “Master or Maestro”), when in fact there is no such thing. There are many words like this. The word “time” is one of my favorites. We create the concept because it is useful, it enables us to organize our experience into a framework that we can use to live effective lives, in other words, to have POWER. But then we forget we made it up! We think it’s real! We made up the word to organize our experience about the movement we observe about our own sun, and then we live (unconsciously), as if it were a universal fact. We think there is such a thing as a “day” in other galaxies, as if when it is Tuesday here, we think it is Tuesday on Alpha Centuari. WRONG!

So, there are words that we create that do not actually point to objective “things” that we can touch or even recognize. They are simply conditional concepts, created for our use, to give us power. If we keep this in mind, we will have, and increase, that power. If we forget that we created these words, these concepts to begin with, they will control us and limit us, taking our power instead of giving it to us.

If we forget we made up the word time (which has even been proven scientifically by Einstein to have no “objective”, but only a “relative” existence), if we think it is a “something” out “there”, then we can be afraid, get stressful, do the worry thing, because since we think it is a real substance, we are afraid we are going to run out of it!

Now, Perfection is like that. There is no such thing. It is a concept meant to empower us, if we use it correctly. If I think it really exists, and some people are “perfect”, some guitarists are “perfect”, and I should be “perfect”, I will always come up short, since I will always find something in me that could stand a little improvement.

Perfection, like Time, is an intangible, a concept. It is like a mirage in front of us. We reach for it, we travel to it, and it disappears when we get there, to be replaced by something else, a little further up ahead. The purpose of consciously using the concept is to bring out the best in us.

Perfection is an individual thing. It is your awareness of what your next possibility is. Without an awareness of your next possibility, and a striving toward it, you cannot grow. If something is "perfect" it really means it is complete, nothing can be added to it without diminishing it, and making it imperfect. Well, as a guitarist, or as a person, you will never be complete. Nor should you wish to be. To be a perfect person, or guitar player, would mean you had stopped getting better, which is just no fun.

To live these words in your life, you must have a commitment to growth. You must always be “sharpening” your awareness and sensitivity. You must always feel a sense of “creative dis-satisfaction” with where you presently are. You must strive for that vision up ahead, and become bored when you get there, and look further.

As a guitarist, as in life, you get what you settle for. If getting half the notes is good enough for you, fine, be a “good enough” guitarist. If you never even take the trouble to record yourself and listen back to how you really sound, fine, stay in the dark. Keep the fantasy bubble floating until such time as you might have to play in front of other people, who will hear how you actually sound, and let them burst the bubble.


For myself, I am only happy when I am attempting to meet some new challenge. As soon as I accomplish that, I am looking for the next one. Like a shark must constantly be moving, and a rat must constantly be gnawing at something, I find I have to be always moving into and chewing on challenges.

I am actually very happy to discover things wrong with my playing. I was so happy when I noticed that a little tension in my 3rd finger, coming from using the 2nd, was causing me a problem in many areas of my playing. I immediately set out to attack the problem, and improve the situation. I was so happy to have discovered this flaw, since I knew it was the first step to a “new, improved me” as a player.

And as I observe myself and other people, I come to the conclusion that this attitude is one of the primary reasons I have developed to an advanced level as a guitarist.

Let me leave you with one of the most inspiring things I have ever read, in relation to this topic, written by Pepe Romero, one of the world's greatest players -  He writes this after his father’s death in 1996 (his father was his lifelong teacher):

"The greatest, most cherished lessons were those that I had with him during his last year. I started the year with firm confidence in my maturity and perfection as a guitarist and as a musician. But my father, with his love,and his knowledge, taught me more in this year that I can ever learn in he rest of my life. We had a lesson every single day that I was at home.

The collection of music I play (on this recording), was an essential part of the repertoire he gave to my brothers and me, so that through our love of it, we could search for beauty and the unattainable perfection that is the guiding light of all the great servants of music."

I hope that you, Charles, and all my readers, will remember those eloquent last words of Pepe’s, “the unattainable perfection that is the GUIDING LIGHT of all the GREAT SERVANTS of music”.



article 1
Playing Plateaus - How To Get Off!
Every guitar player gets stuck on a plateau from time to time, unable to get better on guitar. Here is what the great players do..................
> Read More...
article 2
Great Guitar Players Give Advice You'd Better Not Follow! Understanding "Auto Correct"
Here is an excellent question about building speed on guitar that is a great area of confusion for guitar students. It shows how careful we must be when listening to the advice of great players!
> Read More...
article 3
Creating Coordination with Coupling
Coupling is the bringing together, into one playing moment and motion, of two or more events necessary to produce a note. It is done by intense focus on the tactile sensations of fingers on strings.
> Read More...
article 4
Measuring Your Progress On Guitar
Guitar students practice every day, but often have no idea if they are making any progress. There are ways of measuring your progress on guitar, and we have to know them, and use them.
> Read More...
article 5
Guitar Speed Exercises: Are They Working For You?
You can find guitar speed exercises all over the web, and in thousands of books. Many guitar students have a pile of these books, but no speed in their fingers. Here's why!
> Read More...
article 6
It's Not A Problem, It's A Process
Attitude is everything when it comes to learning guitar. Learning how to see every problem as a process is the key to becoming a great guitar player. In this article, I explain how to do this.
> Read More...
article 7
Practicing One Thing is Practicing Everything!
If you know how to learn one thing really well on guitar, you know how to learn anything. If you cannot learn one thing well, you cannot learn anything well. Correct practice changes everything!
> Read More...
article 8
9 Questions to Ask Yourself When You Practice
Here are 9 critical things you MUST be aware of when you practice guitar. Lack of awareness of these things is the root of endless problems.
> Read More...
article 9
Playing From The String
"Playing From The String" is one of the secrets of the masters of guitar. All good players are doing this, even if they don't know what it means! Here's what it mean.....
> Read More...
article 10
The 5 Minute Practice Session
Finding a block of time for guitar practice is sometimes difficult. Don't go for days without touching those strings you love! Learn how to make solid progress in just 5 minutes!
> Read More...
article 11
Am I Too Old To Learn Guitar?
A lot of "grown ups" want to fulfill their lifelong dream of playing the guitar. But. one nasty, nagging doubt holds them back. Cheer up...here's the good news!
> Read More...
article 12
Natural Talent - Do I Need It?
What is "natural talent" for guitar? Few people know, yet many people are sure they don't have it when it comes to guitar! Here is what "natural talent" really means......
> Read More...
article 13
The 2 Types of Growth On Guitar: Horizontal & Vertical
There are two kinds of growth we can experience on guitar. I call them Vertical & Horizontal Growth.Both are necessary, but Vertical growth is hard to come by!
> Read More...
article 14
Agressive Guitar Practice
Many guitar students make little or no progress because their practicing is not aggressive enough. When you practice, your mind must have the energy of a hurricane and the tenacity of a pit bull!
> Read More...
article 15
Review Is Required
Reviewing material we have already worked on, and applying our new and improved skills is essential for reaching our full potential on guitar.
> Read More...
article 16
Guitar Principles Recommended Metronomes
A metronome is necessary for guitar practice. Some metronomes are better than others when it comes to doing powerful and correct practice.
> Read More...
article 17
Why You Should Use A Metronome For Guitar Practice
Knowing how to use a metronome when you practice guitar WILL make you a better player! Here's why...
> Read More...
article 18
Double Trouble
Sometimes the way to make something better on guitar is to make it worse first!
> Read More...
article 19
The Importance Of Repertoire
If you have played guitar for more than six months and you do not have a few things you can play from beginning to end, something is seriously wrong!
> Read More...
article 20
Changing Bad Habits On Guitar
Virtually all beginners on guitar unknowingly form bad habits. They can last for decades, making you less of a guitar player than you can be. Here is how to get rid of your bad habits.
> Read More...
article 21
Guitar Practice Organization
Here's how to find the time for guitar practice and how to organize it. There are 4 essential categories of practice you must organize in your guitar practice schedule...here they are...
> Read More...
you might also like
Technique vs. Musical Feeling
Read More...
Guitar Foundation Exercises
Read More...
Play "Day Tripper"!
Read More...
Finger Rise: A Disease of the Left Hand
Read More...
 
IN THIS SECTION
Playing Plateaus - How To Get Off!
Great Guitar Players Give Advice You'd Better Not Follow! Understanding "Auto Correct"
Creating Coordination with Coupling
Measuring Your Progress On Guitar
NEWSLETTER SIGNUP
RECEIVE “THE POWER OF TEN”
We Never Email More then Once a Week.
Upon signup receive 10 ARTICLES THAT WILL TRANSFORM YOUR GUITAR PLAYING.
FEATURED CONTENT

156 - Why Is The Principles The Best Way to Learn Guitar?

All other guitar methods have serious flaws that leave you struggling on guitar. The Principles is different....

16 - Learn To Play a Guitar by Learning HOW to Practice!

Everything that happens when you play is the direct result of what you do when you practice. Learn to train your fingers EFFECTIVELY when you practice guitar.

18 - Your First Perfect Guitar Lesson

Many guitar players carry for a lifetime the mistakes they learned when first learning how to play the instrument... Tips to avoid this can be found here!

28 - The Basic Chords On Guitar

These are the chords you want to learn first!